Once Upon a River by Diane Setterfield
460 pages

What’s it about?
 This novel begins over a 100 years ago and takes place along the banks of the Thames river in England.  The story begins when a badly injured man wanders into a rural Inn with a 4 year-old girl in his arms.  He immediately collapses and the owners and patrons of the Inn take charge of the girl.  She seems to have drowned in the river and is thought dead.  The local nurse arrives and also believes the child to be dead.  While sitting with the body she is surprised to find a pulse reemerging in the child.  Stories abound and three different families come forward to lay claim to the young girl who was dead and lived again.  The mystery of the young girl who died and returned to life is the heart of this story.  

What did it make me think about?
 This novel is about stories- the ones we hand down as well as the stories we tell ourselves to make sense of our world. 

Should I read it?
 So I really enjoyed Diane Setterfield's previous book "The Thirteenth Tale" and was expecting an easy, quick read.  This book was not that!  The first half of the book was pretty slow.  It sets up all that happens in the second half of the book, but it takes a long time to get there.  The book has great characters and the setting is wonderful.  The river is almost a character in itself.  I am not sure how to review this one. I did enjoy it but it was also easy to put down for the first 200 pages.  If you have patience this one will reward you.

Quote-
​​"It was a solstice night, the longest night of the year.  For weeks the days had been shrinking, first gradually, then precipitously, so that it was now dark by mid-afternoon.  As is well-known, when the moon hours lengthen, human beings come adrift from the regularity of their mechanical clocks.  They nod at noon, dream in waking hours, open their eyes wide to the pitch-black night.  It is a time fo magic.  And as the borders between night and day stretch to their thinnest, so too do the borders between worlds.  Dreams and  stories merge with lived experience, the dead the the living brush against each other in their comings and goings, and the past and the present touch and overlap.  Unexpected things happen."

If you like this try-
Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and His yeats of Pilgrimage by Haruki Murakami
​Circe by Madeline Miller
The Buried Giant by Kazoo Ishiguro
The Rules of Magic by Alice Hoffman

7 1/2 stars

The Paragon Hotel by Lindsay Faye
414 pages

What’s it about?
This book takes place in 1921 and goes back and forth between New York City and Portland, Oregon.  In New York City Alice James is a burgeoning mafioso. When things go bad she flees to Portland to recover from a bullet wound and hide.  She lands at The Paragon Hotel.  The Paragon is an all black establishment- in a city that bans blacks from living.

What did it make me think about?
This book of historical fiction shines a spotlight on Oregon’s racist beginnings.  Having been born in Portland I found this slice of history fascinating. It explains Oregon’s two different faces- progressive on one hand and very conservative on the other.  Who knew that Oregon had a law  banning black people from living in the state?  Who knew that the KKK has been active there?  

Should I read it?
This book tells two different stories simultaneously and I much preferred the Oregon story to the Little Italy story.  Others might feel differently.  On the positive side- it was nice to see female characters not portrayed as helpless. On the negative- sometimes the dialogue was a little too glib for me.  As a whole it is a book has some flaws, but it was interesting and the plot moves along.  This book will appeal to fans of historical fiction.
​
Quote-
“ I know what the KKK means in the south, and it makes me sick. But around here, there are hardly any blacks to begin with, you understand. The clan is a political rally and tool and a charitable club. It’s all America first with them – promoting jobs for hard-working protestants over Orientals and Catholic immigrants, protesting Jew banking, defending motherhood and maidenhood. Fundraisers, not lunch mobs.”

If you liked this try-
​Lazaretto by Diane McKinney-Whetstone
​Love and Other Consolation Prizes by Jamie Ford
Varina by Charles Frazier
The Second Mrs. Hockaday by Susan Rivers

​7 1/2 stars
​

​A Terrible Country by Keith Gessen

What’s it about?
This novel follows Andrei from the United States to Russia.  Andrei is an aspiring academic specializing in Russian Literature.  As no career prospects are panning out, he answers his older brother's call to come to Russia and help take care of his 90 year old grandmother for a short time.  We watch Andrei try to assimilate into a very new Russia. 

What did it make me think about?
Why have I not heard more about this book?  I have read so many books on the Soviet Union, but not many on life in Russia more recently.  This fictional novel was a fascinating glimpse into a country that seems to always be striving towards a new type of society.

Should I read it?
I highly recommend this book and am very surprised that it has not garnered more attention.  The characters are magnificent and it is a novel that is illuminating as well as thought provoking. Plus Keith Gessen writes with a deadpan style that allows his humor to shine- and I always love that. This one will be high on my list for 2019.  Nice to start the year out with such a good book!
​
Quote-
“His parents had come from the Soviet Union, as mine had, and at around the same time.  Like many of us, he’d grown up speaking Russian, and like many of us he’d inherited his parents’ ambivalence toward the country they’d escaped.  Our parents had been so skeptical of Russia, so fearful of the Russians, that they had uprooted their lives, put everything in boxes, and gone to the post office dozens of times to ship their books to America, just to get away.  But they also remained bound to Russia by a million ties of memory and habit and affection.  They watched Russian movies, shopped at Russian stores, and preferred Russian candy.”

“More to the point, would I be able to stay in Moscow indefinitely?  On the one hand it was appealing. I didn’t care that much about good coffee. And I liked the food. But the daily grind of life was something else.  Just to do anything, to get my skates sharpened, to get a library book-to get from one part of the city to another- was an unbelievable hassle.  What in New York took twenty minutes, here took an hour.  What in New York took an hour, here took pretty much all day.  It wore you down. The frowns on the faces of the people wore you down.  The lies on the television too, after awhile, wore you down.”

9 stars

Census by Jesse Ball
241 pages

What’s it about?
A widower learns that he does not have long to live.  He decides to take his adult son on a trip to see the country.  His son has Down’s Syndrome and the father worries about what his son’s life will be like once he passes.  Taking a job with the census, the father and son go out on the road.

What did it make me think about?
This was such an unusual novel.  The son is at the center of the novel- and yet, all we know of him is what we can glean from the reactions of others.  The author says in the forward, “it occurred to me last month that I would like to write a book about my brother.  I felt, and feel, that people with Down syndrome are not fully understood.  What is in my heart when I consider him and his life is something so tremendous, so full of light, that I thought I must write a book that helps people to see what it is like to know and love a Down syndrome boy or girl.  It is not like what you would expect, and it is not like it is ordinarily portrayed and explained.  It is something else, different than that.”  I must confess that the forward was what initially kept me turning the pages when the book seemed difficult.  

Should I read it?
This was a beautiful and sparse story.  It is not an easy read-  you will need to pay attention. This book was quite unexpected.  It was also a bit of work.  I am very glad to have read it though.

Quote-
“However, out in the world I have come to see that he who looks too hard for any particular thing, though he may find it, will certainly miss the most wondrous and strange things he passes, though they stare him in the face.”

If you like this try-
The Animals by Christian Kiefer
The Enchanted by Rene Denfield
The Incendiaries by R.O. Kwon
The Flamethrowers by Rachel Kushner

This is a link to an interesting You Tube video with the author:
​https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=47-ygyE-iUY&feature=youtu.be


8 stars-be prepared to work for it!